The Trouble with DS101-151

Greetings!

Today, I’m going to try to briefly explain an overall issue I have with DS101-151, and in the coming months I’m certain I’ll have many many more posts about that section, digging into more specific areas, or nuances. This is for three reasons, which I feel a need to disclose:

  1. I’m an Israeli-born American
  2.  I’m Jewish
  3. I catalog materials in that subject area a tremendous amount

So — what we’re looking at is the following:

DS101-151 Israel (Palestine). The Jews

The D class is where History (excepting that of the Americas) is placed, and DS is given for the history of Asia. Let’s take a look at some of the other sectional divisions in the DS class.

DS101-151       Israel (Palestine). The Jews
DS153-154.9    Jordan. Transjordan

DS155-156       Asia Minor
DS161-199       Armenia
DS201-248       Arabian Peninsula. Saudi Arabia
DS251-326       Iran (Persia)
DS327-329.4    Central Asia
DS331-349.9    Southern Asia. Indian Ocean Region
DS350-375       Afghanistan
DS376-392.2    Pakistan
DS393-396.9    Bangladesh. East Pakistan
DS401-486.8    India (Bharat)
DS488-490       Sri Lanka
DS491-492.9    Bhutan
DS493-495.8    Nepal

The divisions are primarily countries, with some regions thrown in as well. What isn’t present in any other provision though, is a country/region equated with an ethnic group.

Again, I’m Israeli, and I’m Jewish. It’s no secret that many Jews are Israeli and many Israelis are Jews. In fact, I would probably not be shocking anyone, least of all the Library of Congress if I acknowledged that there is a relationship between Jewry and Israel. What that relationship is not however, is the biconditional equivalent one set up in the DS101-151 section.

It is from this fundamental categorical placement, that flows many, if not all, my problems with this section, and I will return to it many times in the future.

N.B. Before folks come parping at me about how there are ways to discuss Jews and Jewry outside of Israel, I know, we’ll get there

Advertisements

4 thoughts on “The Trouble with DS101-151

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s